Skip to content
Search Entire Site

For CAN SLIM Returns 20%, Should You Use the Pivot Price or Your Actual Purchase Price? How a 5% Entry Difference Is Calculated

NEO AI Content Center · Published · Sources and corrections

When calculating CAN SLIM’s 20~25% profit-taking threshold, distinguish the return in your actual account from the return measured against the pivot buy point. Two people who buy the same stock at USD 100 and USD 105 will have different returns even when the price reaches USD 120. Failing to distinguish these figures can lead to misjudging when to take profits. Pivot

This post contains Coupang Partners affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calculated

When calculating CAN SLIM’s 20~25% profit-taking threshold, you need to distinguish the return in your actual account from the return measured against the pivot buy point. Two people who buy the same stock at USD 100 and USD 105 will have different returns even when the price reaches USD 120. Failing to distinguish these figures can lead to misjudging when to take profits.

1. Why Are the Pivot Buy Point and the Actual Purchase Price Different?

The pivot is the reference price when a stock breaks out of a suitable price pattern. The actual purchase price is the price at which an investor submits an order and gets it filled.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

The two prices can be the same, but they differ if you buy after the breakout or the price changes during execution.

William O’Neil’s CAN SLIM approach places importance on buying at an appropriate breakout point. Chasing a stock at a price far above its pivot increases the risk of hitting your stop-loss level even during a normal pullback.

MarketSmith’s official explanation also presents the range from the pivot price up to 5% as the buy zone.

So you need to distinguish among these three prices:

Pivot price: the ideal breakout reference identified on the chart

Actual purchase price: the fill price recorded in your account

Current stock price: the market price at the time you calculate the return

For reference, the fact that the price has risen 5% or more above the pivot does not mean you should automatically buy. It is a way to check whether the price has moved outside the appropriate entry range.

2. How Different Are the Returns for Purchases at USD 100 and USD 105?

Let’s assume a stock has a pivot price of USD 100.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

Investor A bought at the pivot price of USD 100, while Investor B bought at USD 105, which is 5% above the pivot.

Assume the stock price rises to USD 120 for both investors.

Investor AInvestor B
Pivot price$100$100
Actual purchase price$100$105
Current stock price$120$120
Unrealized return+20%+14.29%

Author’s calculation: Return = (current stock price - actual purchase price) ÷ actual purchase price × 100

Although the stock reached the same price, USD 120, Investor A has a 20% return, while Investor B has a return of about 14.29%.

Conversely, for both investors to achieve a 20% return relative to their actual purchase price, the stock must rise to the following prices.

Investor AInvestor B
Actual purchase price$100$105
20% target price$120$126
Gain from pivot20%26%

If the actual purchase price is 5% higher, the stock must rise further to deliver the same 20% return.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

That is why you should not confuse the pivot price with the actual fill price.

3. Which Price Does William O’Neil’s 20~25% Rule Use as Its Reference?

It is important to distinguish between the original sources here.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

In an article William O’Neil contributed directly to January 2004 AAII Journal, he described the general profit-taking threshold as a gain of 20~25% from the purchase price.

By contrast, Investor’s Business Daily’s current investor education materials describe the threshold as a gain of 20~25% from the ideal buy point.

You can avoid confusion by understanding that the two expressions refer to different things: your actual entry price and the reference price used by the strategy.

Your actual account’s gain or loss should be calculated using the fill price.

When evaluating the CAN SLIM strategy, however, you should also record the difference between the preset pivot price and your actual entry price.

For example, if the pivot is USD 100 and you bought at USD 105, you can see how late your entry was relative to the strategy’s ideal entry point.

4. How Does the Reference Price Work Under the 8-Week Holding Rule?

It is important to keep the reference points clear when considering the 20~25% profit-taking threshold and the 8-week holding rule.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

In O’Neil’s original source, he describes an exception: if a stock breaks out of a proper base, gains 20% within 1~3 weeks on strong volume, the overall market is strong, and the stock itself is a high-quality growth leader, hold it for at least 8 weeks.

The 8-week period does not restart on the day the stock reaches a 20% gain.

The rule means holding for at least 8 weeks from the initial breakout buy point.

However, a 20% gain alone does not qualify a stock for the 8-week rule.

An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc
An informational thumbnail explaining the key question: For CAN SLIM returns of 20%, should you use the pivot price or your actual purchase price? How a 5% entry difference is calc

Consider the following conditions together.

Is the overall market in a strong uptrend?

Are the company’s earnings growth and competitive position in its industry strong?

Did the stock break out of a proper base?

Did it gain 20% on strong volume within 1~3 weeks?

The fact that 8 weeks have passed also does not mean you must sell. After that, reassess the price action, volume, institutional buying and selling, and any sell signals.

5. Additional Costs to Consider When Calculating Your Actual Return

The calculation above is a simple return based only on the stock’s price change.

When checking the return in an actual account, investors in U.S. stocks should also consider the following:

1. Buy and sell commissions

2. The price difference incurred when trades are executed

3. Currency conversion costs and exchange-rate fluctuations

4. Taxes applicable to the investor

In particular, returns measured in dollars may differ from returns measured in Korean won.

Even if you make a 20% gain in dollars, your return converted to Korean won may be higher or lower depending on exchange-rate movements.

Also, during sharp price swings or gap moves up or down, your order may not be filled at the price you want.

So you should not treat the strategy’s 20% target and your actual account’s net return as the same thing.

In Closing: Record the Pivot Price and Actual Fill Price Separately

When applying CAN SLIM’s profit-taking rules, it is useful to record both the strategy’s reference price and the purchase price in your actual account.

Pivot price: the ideal breakout reference for the strategy

Actual purchase price: the basis for calculating your account’s gain or loss

20~25% gain: a general reference for taking profits

8-week holding period: an exception rule for stocks with strong breakouts

Entering at an appropriate price is as important as finding a good stock.

If you enter above the pivot, your return will be lower for the same price increase, and the room before reaching your loss limit will also differ.

CAN SLIM is not a formula that guarantees profits by mechanically applying set prices. It is an investment approach that requires you to consider market conditions, the quality of the stock, volume, and the actual fill price together.

※ This article is for informational purposes to help readers understand market trends. It is not a recommendation to invest in any specific stock or asset. You are responsible for your own investment decisions.

This post contains Coupang Partners affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

#CAN SLIM #William O’Neil #Pivot Buy Point #Actual Purchase Price #2025 Profit-Taking #8-Week Holding Rule

Visitor Statistics


Copyright © neoai.kr. All rights reserved.